「玉山計畫」真能救台灣高教?

洪裕宏
陽明大學心智哲學研究所教授

台灣的大學教授的待遇與鄰近國家相比,真的是太低了,加上最近暴衝式的年金改革,退休所得替代率砍一半,造成非常嚴重的高教危機。說執政者無感也不盡然,「玉山計劃」反映了執政當局看到高教人才流失的嚴重性,想要用「玉山計畫」來穩住人心浮浮的高教界,防止高階人才大量流失。然而會有效嗎?還是如許多評論者所說的,「只會讓台灣高教提高崩塌」(管中祥語)?

「玉山計畫」的重點有二:提供五百名額年薪六百萬起,以及公立大學教授學術研究加給月5445元。說真的,在千萬勞工多數都還在為三餐掙扎時,大學教師也沒什麼好怨。可是因為退休年金腰斬,已退的自求多福,在職者必需花很多時間與心力在儲蓄、兼職及理財。多數大學教師沒有祖蔭,有家產可以繼承者是少數。這會重擊大學教師的教學與研究品質。為了求生存,有心也無力像過去一樣,全力投入教學與研究。如此下來,大學的教學與研究品質令人堪慮。

光只是提高教授級的學術研究加給,對解決上述的問題無濟於事。正確做法是不論階級,所有的大學教師(含私校)的本薪大幅度提高,如此可以稍微彌補年金腰斬的災難。光對教授每月加碼5445元,是愚蠢的政策。對教授而言,好處也不大。因為沒有加到本俸,年金依舊腰斬。每月多五千,每年六萬,十五年九十萬,這恐怕連慰問金的效果都沒有,遑論提升大學教授的士氣?

六百萬年薪,五百個員額的計畫也是問題重重。教育部提出的作法是由各校提名,經跨部會國家級審查委員會審定。這是很奇怪的作法。為什麼不相信學校,把經費直接撥下來,由各校自行運用,教育部只要定期考核成效即可。再者,委員會強調跨部會,想必是又要強調「產學相結合」。強調產學連結的思想已經帶來很大的禍害,人文領域往往在這種考慮下被忽視。如果教育部執意要做,我們就悲觀以待,但是執政者不見得會被懲罰,然而國家發展卻已受重創。

回應

JIANBIN1031

JIANBIN1031 mulberry handbags nike shoes outlet canada goose parka michael kors outlet online pandora jewelry michael kors outlet michael kors outlet reebok shoes jerseys wholesale coach outlet online ugg boots clearance canada goose outlet chrome hearts outlet mulberry handbags uggs outlet canada goose outlet cheap oakley sunglasses longchamp pliage nhl jerseys for sale true religion outlet true religion jeans for men true religion jeans sale air max 90 coach outlet online coach factory outlet michael kors outlet clearance michael kors handbags cheap jordans nike air max canada goose coats coach outlet jordan shoes ugg boots canada goose outlet ferragamo outlet cheap uggs oakley sunglasses uggs outlet canada goose jackets true religion jeans sale coach factory outlet cheap oakley sunglasses canada goose outlet michael kors outlet michael kors coach outlet birkenstock shoes ray ban sunglasses uggs outlet canada goose jackets canada goose uk fitflops sale clearance polo outlet canada goose outlet kate spade sale ugg boots michael kors outlet tory burch handbags ugg outlet online canada goose jackets ferragamo outlet coach outlet clearance coach outlet store online clearances christian louboutin sale christian louboutin shoes birkenstock outlet supra shoes canada goose outlet canada goose outlet store canada goose jackets ferragamo outlet cheap mlb jerseys soccer jerseys coach outlet online puma shoes longchamp pas cher longchamp handbags ray ban sunglasses michael kors outlet online ferragamo outlet michael kors outlet online uggs outlet kate spade outlet online store salomon shoes canada goose jackets ralph lauren outlet coach outlet store max 90 polo outlet blackhawks jerseys moncler sale michael kors outlet canada goose jackets cheap nfl jerseys kevin durant shoes oakley sunglasses jordan shoes ray ban sunglasses coach outlet oakley sunglasses adidas nmd r1 kate spade outlet online moncler jackets cheap oakley sunglasses true religion outlet canada goose jackets lacoste polo shirts canada goose outlet michael kors outlet online hermes outlet store nike outlet store coach outlet ray ban sunglasses uggs outlet ugg outlet ray ban sunglasses canada goose outlet store polo outlet online adidas outlet store nhl jerseys wholesale giuseppe zanotti shoes canada goose outlet canada goose outlet coach outlet online pandora outlet moncler outlet uggs outlet ugg boots for women cheap jordans free shipping true religion jeans michael kors outlet online michael kors outlet canada goose uk mont blanc pens polo ralph lauren outlet christian louboutin sale coach handbags coach outlet uggs outlet coach outlet coach outlet online lacoste shirts birkenstock shoes cheap jordan shoes swarovski jewelry burberry outlet sale canada goose jackets cheap oakley sunglasses tory burch outlet online store coach factory outlet christian louboutin shoes true religion outlet true religion outlet uk basketball sneakers michael kors outlet store polo ralph lauren shirts ray ban wayfarer yeezy boost 350 longchamp solde canada goose jackets burberry outlet michael kors bags canada goose outlet polo ralph lauren oakley sunglasses uk cheap ray ban sunglasses fitflops sale clearance coach outlet kate spade outlet michael kors uk michael kors uk canada goose outlet cheap ugg boots lacoste pas cher tory burch outlet canada goose jackets michael kors outlet canada goose jackets ralph lauren ugg outlet coach outlet online oakley sunglasses michael kors outlet clearance oakley sunglasses air jordan shoes michael kors outlet michael kors outlet clearance air max trainers cheap oakley sunglasses canada goose outlet michael kors outlet clearance cheap uggs for sale nfl jerseys wholesale true religion jeans canada goose outlet store polo ralph lauren shirts canada goose coats cheap nba jerseys mcm backpacks cheap ray bans tory burch outlet christian louboutin shoes air max 90 canada goose jackets fred perry polo adidas nmd ugg boots canada goose outlet canada goose outlet store cheap jerseys uggs outlet ray ban sunglasses michael kors outlet polo ralph lauren cheap uggs swarovski outlet herve leger outlet michael kors uk football shirts lebron shoes burberry outlet canada goose outlet store coach outlet online coach outlet coach factory outlet cheap ray ban sunglasses christian louboutin outlet ysl outlet online coach factory outlet canada goose jackets ray-ban sunglasses mac cosmetics coach handbags on sale kobe shoes canada goose outlet kate spade outlet mulberry outlet ugg outlet online nike shoes supra shoes sale mulberry handbags ugg boots clearance cheap ugg boots cazal outlet oakley sunglasses cheap jordans ferragamo shoes mont blanc pens coach outlet coach outlet online pandora charms christian louboutin uk pandora charms uggs outlet christian louboutin outlet cheap uggs yeezy boost michael kors uk coach outlet online swarovski outlet canada goose jackets canada goose outlet canada goose longchamp pliage true religion jeans sale ugg boots canada goose outlet store polo ralph lauren christian louboutin shoes coach handbags on sale michael kors outlet online cleveland cavaliers jerseys coach outlet kobe 9 michael kors outlet ralph lauren polo canada goose outlet store polo ralph lauren swarovski crystal michael kors outlet online nike roshe run thomas sabo coach outlet online fitflops air max 90 ferragamo shoes ray ban sunglasses uk christian louboutin outlet canada goose coats canada goose jackets michael kors factory outlet canada goose jackets nike air huarache burberry outlet true religion outlet coach outlet michael kors handbags coach outlet canada goose jackets ugg boots ugg sale coach factory outlet oakley sunglasses fitflops michael kors outlet oakley sunglasses polo ralph lauren true religion uk swarovski uk ugg boots kate spade handbags canada goose coats michael kors outlet christian louboutin online michael kors outlet online tory burch outlet canada goose outlet canada goose outlet coach outlet canada goose uk oakley sunglasses nba jerseys coach outlet online canada goose outlet ugg outlet online ugg boots clearance cheap uggs coach factory outlet cheap oakley sunglasses ray ban sunglasses kate spade outlet online nike outlet coach outlet store online ugg boots uggs outlet canada goose outlet michael kors outlet clearance oakley sunglasses canada goose outlet oakley sunglasses wholesale canada goose outlet coach factory outlet michael kors outlet clearance louboutin shoes coach outlet online coach outlet online true religion jeans swarovski crystal canada goose jackets canada goose jackets ugg outlet michael kors handbags ralph lauren outlet canada goose outlet ugg outlet online coach outlet michael kors outlet online marc jacobs outlet cheap ugg boots nike store uk oakley sunglasses wholesale reebok trainers ray ban sunglasses nike uk store cheap uggs canada goose jackets michael kors nfl jerseys ralph lauren outlet longchamp pliage ugg outlet tory burch outlet stores coach outlet coach outlet oakley sunglasses wholesale canada goose outlet oakley sunglasses wholesale canada goose jackets ferragamo shoes air huarache michael kors outlet clearance canada goose jackets michael kors handbags ugg outlet ugg boots outlet cheap jordans soccer jerseys wholesale ugg outlet canada goose jackets ralph lauren shirts coach outlet fitflops sale clearance swarovski crystal ugg outlet stores nike shoes uk coach outlet cheap oakley sunglasses prada outlet michael kors outlet clearance nike trainers lacoste outlet coach outlet online true religion jeans oakley sunglasses ugg outlet michael kors outlet canada goose jackets fitflops sale canada goose jackets canada goose uk ugg outlet michael kors outlet online polo ralph lauren mulberry handbags air max 2015 coach handbags cheap jordan shoes michael kors outlet clearance cheap ray bans adidas trainers chrome hearts mbt outlet cheap jordan shoes tory burch outlet mulberry bags ugg boots outlet coach outlet online polo outlet canada goose jackets vans outlet canada goose coats louboutin shoes michael kors outlet clearance michael kors outlet online fitflops oakley sunglasses coach outlet canada goose coats christian louboutin sale michael kors outlet sale longchamp outlet michael kors bags coach outlet store online coach factory outlet canada goose uk tory burch outlet online nike air huarache canada goose jackets mlb jerseys cheap nfl jerseys for sale bottega veneta outlet online ugg boots on sale ray ban sunglasses uk coach outlet online coach outlet online tory burch outlet online fitflops shoes christian louboutin outlet michael kors outlet canada goose outlet store mulberry bags ferragamo shoes ralph lauren outlet cheap ray ban sunglasses tory burch outlet cheap uggs nike nba jerseys kate spade outlet online camisetas futbol baratas michael kors outlet nhl jerseys ralph lauren outlet canada goose uk canada goose coats cheap oakley sunglasses coach outlet online new balance shoes ray ban sunglasses coach outlet canada fred perry polo shirts oakley sunglasses canada goose outlet online ugg outlet air max 90 michael kors factory outlet mulberry handbags tory burch outlet coach outlet canada goose outlet michael kors adidas outlet adidas nmd runner kate spade outlet ray ban sunglasses wholesale canada goose outlet coach outlet store online ugg boots outlet coach outlet online coach outlet store longchamp handbags air max trainers swarovski outlet ralph lauren outlet michael kors canada canada goose outlet store salomon outlet polo outlet stores canada goose uk ralph lauren polo christian louboutin sale nike blazer pas cher coach factory outlet chrome hearts outlet moncler jackets uggs outlet ugg outlet store canada goose outlet online mulberry handbags christian louboutin shoes canada goose jackets links of london jewellery coach outlet ray ban sunglasses los angeles lakers jerseys marc jacobs sale nike trainers longchamp outlet online michael kors outlet ugg boots mcm outlet uggs nike roshe canada goose outlet online christian louboutin shoes coach factory outlet mlb jerseys michael kors handbags coach outlet online michael kors handbags cheap nba jerseys michael kors outlet clearance ugg boots uk ray ban sunglasses canada goose coats mulberry uk prada shoes air max 1 true religion outlet cheap jordans for sale hermes online canada goose coats pandora charms oakley sunglasses canada goose outlet fitflops sale clearance oakley sunglasses wholesale canada goose outlet online canada goose outlet coach factory store coach outlet online ralph lauren polo michael kors handbags true religion jeans michael kors outlet clearance vans shoes polo ralph lauren outlet michael kors handbags new balance outlet ugg outlet canada goose outlet store yeezy boost 350 ugg boots on sale michael kors outlet clearance ecco outlet michael kors outlet true religion jeans coach outlet online true religion jeans coach outlet michael kors outlet michael kors outlet clearance true religion canada thomas sabo charms coach outlet online cheap uggs michael kors outlet clearance ugg boots outlet canada goose jackets michael kors outlet ugg boots clearance coach outlet store online coach outlet clearance herve leger dresses cheap snapbacks canada goose jackets for women ugg outlet store jordan shoes canada goose outlet store michael kors outlet online canada goose black friday nfl jerseys wholesale michael kors outlet clearance hermes outlet ray ban sunglasses bottega veneta outlet canada goose outlet tods outlet online coach handbags outlet canada goose jackets outlet michael kors outlet michael kors outlet michael kors outlet fitflops uk coach outlet store online pandora charms sale clearance polo outlet valentino outlet ray-ban sunglasses nike roshe run canada goose outlet store canada goose outlet store adidas nmd ugg outlet coach factory outlet ralph lauren polo nfl jerseys longchamp outlet nike outlet christian louboutin outlet michael kors outlet online mont blanc outlet canada goose outlet snapbacks wholesale cheap ray ban sunglasses ugg boots clearance nike air max 1 cheap mlb jerseys ugg outlet cheap basketball shoes michael kors outlet online canada goose uk michael kors outlet clearance canada goose outlet kobe 9 elite michael kors outlet canada goose outlet store canada goose outlet online moncler coats nfl jerseys ugg outlet michael kors uggs outlet mac outlet hermes birkin canada goose outlet store snapback hats true religion jeans canada goose outlet nike outlet store coach outlet store online coach outlet online canada goose outlet store michael kors outlet canada goose coats oakley sunglasses fitflops michael kors handbags prada sunglasses michael kors outlet online tory burch outlet stores ugg outlet burberry outlet cheap nfl jerseys air max 90 canada goose outlet coach outlet online ecco shoes cleveland cavaliers jersey tory burch outlet online coach outlet online oakley sunglasses wholesale hermes outlet christian louboutin michael kors outlet ugg boots on sale ralph lauren factory store moncler outlet ray ban sunglasses polo ralph lauren michael kors handbags clearance ralph lauren outlet ugg boots on sale michael kors outlet michael kors outlet nike factory shoes canada goose coats ralph lauren polo coach outlet online foamposite shoes coach outlet cheap oakley sunglasses canada goose coats true religion jeans polo ralph lauren nfl jerseys ugg outlet online clearance canada goose jackets coach outlet adidas wings ugg outlet online kate spade outlet swarovski outlet store ralph lauren outlet polo shirts ugg outlet clearance michael kors outlet true religion jeans prada handbags coach outlet nike factory store canada goose uk coach outlet online canada goose outlet nfl jerseys michael kors outlet clearance ugg outlet canada goose uk true religion jeans soccer cleats mulberry bags michael kors handbags outlet oakley sunglasses wholesale ugg outlet coach outlet store online swarovski crystal air max uk cazal sunglasses coach factory outlet coach factory outlet polo ralph lauren outlet mulberry handbags sale canada goose outlet canada goose jackets men oakley sunglasses coach outlet coach outlet polo outlet michael kors outlet online polo ralph lauren ed hardy outlet michael kors handbags ugg outlet ray ban sunglasses outlet michael kors outlet nike air max 90 michael kors outlet clearance swarovski crystal ferragamo shoes oakley sunglasses wholesale coach outlet online coach factory outlet michael kors outlet oakley sunglasses wholesale coach outlet online canada goose outlet tory burch sandals swarovski crystal michael kors outlet clearance nike shoes mulberry sale canada goose coats coach outlet store canada goose outlet air max uk canada goose jackets cheap ray ban sunglasses canada goose outlet canada goose outlet online kate spade outlet hermes outlet store puma outlet jordan shoes coach outlet coach factory outlet longchamp solde canada goose outlet uggs outlet michael kors outlet coach outlet online coach outlet canada goose outlet longchamp outlet michael kors outlet store canada goose jackets polo outlet coach outlet online uggs canada ugg outlet store kd shoes fitflops uk longchamp solde ugg outlet store canada goose uk ralph lauren longchamp outlet oakley sunglasses ysl outlet ugg outlet kobe shoes canada goose uk true religion jeans cheap soccer jerseys ugg boots canada goose uk ugg outlet coach outlet clearance cheap nhl jerseys canada goose outlet canada goose outlet online canada goose jackets ugg outlet adidas uk ugg boots clearance tory burch outlet online store prada shoes for men ralph lauren polo kate spade outlet store pandora jewelry tory burch outlet canada goose outlet cheap oakley sunglasses soccer jerseys michael kors outlet polo outlet coach outlet christian louboutin outlet canada goose outlet store michael kors outlet online coach outlet ralph lauren outlet pandora charms polo ralph lauren adidas store nfl jersey wholesale coach outlet oakley sunglasses sale michael kors outlet clearance ugg boots cheap ugg boots nike outlet ugg boots on sale cheap football shirts lebron james shoes ralph lauren outlet canada goose outlet store longchamp bags prada outlet online canada goose jackets mulberry bags canada goose coats ray ban sunglasses canada goose outlet store canada goose outlet coach outlet reebok shoes cheap ray ban sunglasses canada goose outlet clearance canada goose jackets mulberry uk ugg boots on sale cheap ugg boots ugg boots michael kors outlet polo ralph lauren outlet michael kors outlet clearance canada goose jackets coach factory outlet air force 1 shoes ralph lauren polo canada goose outlet ugg outlet prada sunglasses for women tory burch shoes oakley sunglasses uggs outlet michael kors outlet clearance moncler outlet online nike free running oakley sunglasses wholesale nba jerseys wholesale ralph lauren polo polo ralph lauren ugg boots prada bags polo ralph lauren shirts ferragamo shoes sale lakers jerseys nike store michael kors outlet clearance montblanc pens polo ralph lauren outlet ugg cyber monday ugg boots ray bans ferragamo shoes uggs outlet ugg boots outlet ugg outlet sale ray ban sunglasses cheap jordans uggs outlet cheap ray ban sunglasses basketball shoes yeezy boost oakley sunglasses polo ralph lauren michael kors outlet clearance michael kors outlet online coach factory outlet moncler jackets ugg boots clearance canada goose jackets ugg outlet longchamp handbags swarovski jewelry cheap oakley sunglasses hermes birkin bag ray-ban sunglasses hermes belts ugg outlet store ugg outlet nfl jersey wholesale coach factory outlet coach outlet store online ugg boots ray bans polo ralph lauren tory burch outlet online nike outlet online oakley sunglasses nike air max 2015 ugg outlet canada goose cyber monday michael kors outlet cheap nike shoes michael kors outlet online longchamp handbags uggs outlet michael kors outlet clearance burberry canada nike factory outlet canada goose parka coach outlet online polo ralph lauren canada goose uk canada goose jackets michael kors outlet online ugg outlet ferragamo outlet moncler coats coach factory outlet michael kors outlet online michael kors outlet online canada goose nike shoes oakley sunglasses wholesale links of london nike blazer pas cher polo ralph lauren ed hardy clothing lacoste soldes coach outlet canada goose outlet store ugg canada michael kors outlet coach handbags online outlet cheap oakley sunglasses cheap jordans ugg outlet air max 90 true religion outlet store ugg clearance coach outlet longchamp handbags longchamp outlet coach outlet kobe bryants shoes coach outlet store online oakley sunglasses sale coach outlet online ugg boots outlet snapbacks wholesale uggs outlet coach outlet moncler outlet michael kors outlet online ralph lauren uk nike air force 1 christian louboutin shoes canada goose outlet store longchamp handbags canada goose coats canada goose coats michael kors outlet ugg black friday michael kors outlet clearance coach outlet store online coach outlet store online longchamp outlet online burberry outlet store pandora charms sale clearance cheap oakley sunglasses tory burch outlet stores cheap ugg boots ralph lauren outlet air huarache prada shoes on sale asics shoes michael kors outlet nike free 5 nhl jerseys coach outlet online longchamp outlet store canada goose jackets louboutin shoes michael kors outlet online air max shoes polo ralph lauren oakley sunglasses wholesale coach handbags online outlet canada goose outlet store michael kors outlet nike trainers uk ralph lauren polo longchamp bags cheap oakley sunglasses canada goose outlet adidas wings shoes christian louboutin sale polo ralph lauren chicago blackhawks jerseys ray ban sunglasses coach factory outlet cheap ray ban sunglasses christian louboutin shoes ugg outlet store ugg boots clearance coach outlet canada goose uk coach factory outlet canada goose outlet max 1 burberry outlet store air max 90 ugg outlet uggs outlet oakley sunglasses sale ralph lauren polo shirts canada goose outlet canada goose outlet store ray ban sunglasses michael kors outlet clearance ralph lauren shirts christian louboutin shoes ugg boots cheap michael kors handbags ugg boots outlet pandora jewelry canada goose outlet store longchamp bags cheap oakley sunglasses nike air max 90 ugg outlet uggs outlet chrome hearts online store fitflops sale clearance kate spade outlet coach outlet store online uggs outlet cheap ugg boots cheap oakley sunglasses true religion jeans mulberry handbags mlb jerseys wholesale coach canada coach outlet canada goose jackets on sale ralph lauren uk pandora jewellery ugg outlet online ralph lauren michael kors outlet online ray ban sunglasses ralph lauren polo shirts michael kors uk moncler jackets michael kors handbags outlet nike air max 90 kate spade canada goose jackets ugg boots true religion jeans ugg boots canada goose outlet store ugg outlet michael kors outlet canada goose jackets polo ralph lauren outlet cheap ray bans true religion uk mbt shoes nike outlet online longchamp pas cher canada goose outlet store michael kors outlet canada goose parka canada goose outlet true religion jeans true religion outlet canada goose coats ferragamo outlet michael kors outlet online canada goose uk ugg outlet ralph lauren pas cher uggs outlet uggs outlet nike roshe one michael kors outlet cheap ray ban sunglasses nike foamposite cheap nfl jerseys soccer shoes canada goose outlet michael kors factory outlet uggs outlet ugg boots coach outlet store online ugg boots cyber monday michael kors outlet online michael kors christian louboutin shoes coach outlet online cartier watches true religion jeans ralph lauren tods outlet canada goose uk polo ralph lauren christian louboutin shoes ugg outlet mulberry outlet,mulberry handbags outlet ugg boots clearance canada goose outlet online kate spade outlet online michael kors factory outlet cheap ray ban sunglasses nba jerseys nfl jersey wholesale oakley sunglasses kobe bryant shoes canada goose outlet store coach canada michael kors handbags canada goose outlet store pandora outlet michael kors outlet christian louboutin nike shoes for women cheap jordan shoes ugg boots ray ban sunglasses michael kors outlet online nike store uk true religion outlet canada goose jackets ugg outlet canada goose outlet uggs outlet canada goose uk true religion outlet store michael kors outlet clearance michael kors outlet online michael kors outlet stores true religion outlet coach outlet store online cheap nhl jerseys michael kors outlet oakley sunglasses wholesale cheap snapbacks fitflops sale clearance cheap uggs coach outlet online converse shoes sale mac tools michael kors black friday fitflops sale clearance cheap oakley sunglasses coach outlet online asics running shoe canada goose jackets nike trainers canada goose outlet canada goose outlet store ugg boots on sale fitflops shoes coach outlet uggs outlet canada goose coats uggs outlet coach factory outlet ugg boots tory burch outlet coach handbags hermes belt pandora outlet ray ban sunglasses outlet michael kors outlet online canada goose coats coach outlet longchamp pas cher mbt shoes outlet mulberry outlet cartier outlet oakley sunglasses ralph lauren outlet stores michael kors wallets for women fitflops ugg boots giuseppe zanotti outlet cheap nfl jerseys wholesale ugg outlet coach outlet michael kors cyber monday christian louboutin outlet ugg boots black friday ugg outlet canada goose outlet adidas shoes true religion outlet ugg clearance canada goose outlet store ugg boots on sale michael kors outlet online birkenstock sandals jordan 4 michael kors outlet online polo outlet coach outlet store ugg outlet online clearance longchamp solde kate spade outlet online store uggs on sale valentino shoes polo ralph lauren michael kors outlet uggs outlet ray bans lacoste polo michael kors outlet air max shoes ugg boots australia swarovski uk coach outlet store uggs outlet longchamp pliage moncler coats michael kors handbags michael kors outlet clearance michael kors outlet online cheap ugg boots uggs outlet canada goose jackets michael kors outlet online fitflops outlet true religion outlet christian louboutin outlet michael kors wallets oakley sunglasses wholesale ferragamo shoes ugg outlet coach factory outlet futbol baratas michael kors uk converse shoes uggs outlet reebok outlet store canada goose outlet michael kors bags mulberry bags canada goose coats canada goose coats polo outlet canada goose jackets coach outlet michael kors outlet michael kors outlet clearance cheap jerseys wholesale canada goose jackets longchamp pas cher air jordan 4

mt1024 cheap nfl

mt1024
cheap nfl jerseys

ralph lauren uk

pandora charms

mbt shoes

michael kors handbags

uggs outlet

nike shoes

ralph lauren outlet

pandora charms

ralph lauren uk

canada goose jackets

ralph lauren outlet online

michael kors handbags

louis vuitton outlet

coach outlet online

air jordans

ray ban sunglasses

pandora uk

moncler jackets

salvatore ferragamo shoes

kate spade outlet

ugg boots outlet

ugg outlet

north face jackets

nike store

michael kors outlet online

coach outlet

pandora charms

ugg boots

longchamp outlet

uggs outlet

cheap jordans

uggs outlet

jordan retro

cheap mlb jerseys

canada goose jackets

moncler outlet

ugg boots

canada goose outlet

oakley sunglasses

pandora charms

canada goose jackets

moncler outlet

adidas outlet

canada goose jackets

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

air jordans

canada goose outlet

canada goose jackets

cheap ray ban sunglasses

canada goose outlet

polo outlet

pandora charms

moncler jackets

cheap uggs

uggs outlet

burberry outlet

coach outlet online

louis vuitton outlet

coach outlet

nike outlet

adidas yeezy shoes

ugg outlet

coach outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

canada goose jackets

cheap uggs

north face outlet

coach factory outlet

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors outlet

coach outlet online

coach outlet

louis vuitton outlet

christian louboutin outlet

coach outlet

cheap jordans

pandora

ralph lauren outlet

oakley sunglasses

ralph lauren outlet

coach factory outlet

coach outlet

pandora outlet

coach factory outlet

pandora jewelry

michael kors handbags

ugg outlet

canada goose clothing
mt1024

---------歡迎發表回應 以促進公共議題討論---------
惟與討論主題無關或惡意人身攻擊的回應,本版保留刪除權利